giacomozucco on Nostr: Tbf, I don't see the post as example of mindless "taproot is bad" slogans. I think ...
Tbf, I don't see the post as example of mindless "taproot is bad" slogans. I think it's correct that *if* we know in advance that different forks will have to change output formats, it's better (at least ceteris paribus) to batch them together, to minimize anonset and compatibility bootstrapping issues. I think the specific objection is that, in this case, it was *not* clear at all CISA (which as you say is very complex) would have required a new format! Even intra-input aggregation wasn't really very clear back them, cfr Musig->Musig2, Frost, etc.. The "70% discount" fake news is indeed weird and counterproductive to the discussion. Even if I am worried of the spread of a symmetrically uninformed meme about CISA incentives being entirely "irrelevant": 15% is still relevant in likely high-fee scenarios (even accounting for coordination costs), and replacing witness discount with CISA could get us closer to 40%. But yeah, a lot of confusion unfortunately. Even about the "ordinal inscriptions" wave being "because of taproot".
Published at
2023-03-21 14:57:34Event JSON
{
"id": "29d4fe9664f347d9480a5dbe2162510271bbf341d949ecbd29d4d86ac8b68b30",
"pubkey": "ef151c7a380f40a75d7d1493ac347b6777a9d9b5fa0aa3cddb47fc78fab69a8b",
"created_at": 1679410654,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"178ce62b4f36b15baf0ff5b345ff5bacb0b3acd91a7ccf98f55eee31fe4c1fb8",
"",
"root"
],
[
"p",
"ef151c7a380f40a75d7d1493ac347b6777a9d9b5fa0aa3cddb47fc78fab69a8b"
],
[
"p",
"675b84fe75e216ab947c7438ee519ca7775376ddf05dadfba6278bd012e1d728"
]
],
"content": "Tbf, I don't see the post as example of mindless \"taproot is bad\" slogans. I think it's correct that *if* we know in advance that different forks will have to change output formats, it's better (at least ceteris paribus) to batch them together, to minimize anonset and compatibility bootstrapping issues. I think the specific objection is that, in this case, it was *not* clear at all CISA (which as you say is very complex) would have required a new format! Even intra-input aggregation wasn't really very clear back them, cfr Musig-\u003eMusig2, Frost, etc.. The \"70% discount\" fake news is indeed weird and counterproductive to the discussion. Even if I am worried of the spread of a symmetrically uninformed meme about CISA incentives being entirely \"irrelevant\": 15% is still relevant in likely high-fee scenarios (even accounting for coordination costs), and replacing witness discount with CISA could get us closer to 40%. But yeah, a lot of confusion unfortunately. Even about the \"ordinal inscriptions\" wave being \"because of taproot\".",
"sig": "ed77917e52f3a6d7d0b02d8589127913e5515fff17cdc31c41afce41dc711badf45e23bd0f297cab98a2eeb4fffba39f37c82b7f5f2ddb9c1e1d52709d8ca3a0"
}